Before I move on with this historical overview, I need to point out a likely error. Some weeks ago I posted a photo that I found in 2013. I thought it pictured the Avenue M station on the Brighton line. Subsequent research, however, casts doubt on this. First, Avenue M was never used as the station name for Brighton trains prior to 1907. Since the railroad’s 1878 inception, it was called Greenfield. Until 1906 that is, when a tattered 1906 BRT map in the Brooklyn Public Library’s collection showed the stop as “Elm Avenue.”

1906 BRT Map

On this same map, above, the Canarsie line is depicted in the upper center. The BRT had just gained control of this line, which descended from elevated tracks in East New York powered by third rails to E. 105th Street near Foster Avenue. Thereafter, it ran via electric trolley wires to Canarsie Landing, on a street-level private right of way between E. 95th and E. 96th Street, parallel to Rockaway Parkway. And one of the stops was “Avenue L”…Well, that’s interesting.

By way of background, that area of Canarsie, bordered on the southeast by Seaview Avenue, was then being developed as “Seaview Terrace.”

1907 May 12 – Brooklyn Daily Eagle

Now let’s look at that photo of the Avenue M station again:

Avenue M Photo

Notice the sign on the left hanging from a wooden pole. It is badly faded, but one can make out the words “Seaview Terrace.” Yikes!

But why didn’t the station sign read “Avenue L” if this was indeed picturing the Canarsie line? ‘Tis a puzzlement, indeed. The Canarsie right of way was abandoned in 1942. But thanks to a trail leading from a FaceBook group called the “Brooklyn Rapid Transit Els,” I eventually found this photo of a trolley, apparently not too far from Avenue L on that long-gone extension to Canarsie Landing (thanks to the George Conrad Collection at et alia):

Circa 1940 Trolley Near Avenue M

Notice the wire fencing and white posts behind the rear of the trolley…Now, look at the Avenue M photo again…Hmmm…Looks like I’m a moron again.

My best hypothesis for all this? The Canarsie line, exercising an abundance of helpfulness, posted signs for Avenue M at one end of the trolley stop, and Avenue L at the other. If I’m wrong, please feel free to sue me.

By the way, this research answered another question I was always too embarrassed to ask: “Why are there streets in Brownsville, East New York and Canarsie with the name “Rockaway”? The answer? Those roads led to Canarsie Landing where steamboats once crossed placid Jamaica Bay to Rockaway Beach. Who knew? Not me.